Sunday, October 19, 2014

Beatboxers and their Linguistic Capabilities

After Professor Sumner demonstrated the change in pitch between the vowels [i] and [ɑ] by flicking her throat, I showed everyone around me just how cool language production is. We also learned that by flicking our throats 150 to 200 times per second, we would be replicating the vibrations of our vocal folds which produce the sounds from inside our throats. At the time, it amazed me that we could hear definitive pitch changes simply by striking our throats as we change the position of our vocal folds. This reminded me of beatboxers and their ability to produce a litany of sounds, with the same speech anatomy used to produce spoken language.

In class, we watched a clip on how a beatboxer's lips, tongue, and throat move in order to form the sounds they make. Beatboxers don't try to replicate sounds from their respective languages, but rather sounds from instruments. For this reason, beatboxing is also referred to as vocal percussion. Though, the sounds in beatboxing aren't usually sounds found traditionally in spoken language, many of them are based in common sounds found in languages around the world. For example, a beatbox tutorial on Wikihow starts out with the “classic kick drum,” which is at first a [b], but with added pressure becomes more 'drum-like.' The article goes on to detail how to go from a [ts] to a “hi-hat,” from a [pf] to a “classic snare drum,” and more. My interest in beatboxers comes from the same place as many other linguists. They use the same muscles and organs to produce beatboxing that all speakers use to produce language. Additionally, beatboxers create sounds that originate from spoken language, but are not from languages they speak naturally.

Looking further into the subject, I happened upon Standard Beatbox Notation, essentially a written language for beatboxing. Of course, beatboxing is not a language as these sounds carry no semantic content, but having written notation presupposes a standard way to produce many of the more basic sounds found in beatboxing. I previously stated that beatboxing tutorials often have beginners start with common sounds. Gretchen McCulloch, a linguist and Slate editor, alluded to this topic when she discussed studies done by USC, looking at how beatboxers formed sounds. These studies also looked at how connected these sounds were to spoken languages. However, what I found most astonishing were the ramifications of beatboxing's basis in language and its capability to produce sounds beyond the beatboxer's natural language.


English speakers who beatbox use parts of their mouth and vocal tracts that aren't widely used in English. They have to, as they naturally experiment with the sudden liberty of their mouth and voice. Yet, in producing these sounds, they expand their sound repertoire beyond their own natural language. McCulloch's article juxtaposes a click from a beatbox tutorial video with a click from a Southern African language, KhoeKhoegowab. The same sound is produced. Ejective consonants are also used in beatboxing, and other languages around the world, but are not apparent in English. I am unsure if there are studies on this subject, but I would offer that beatboxers have an easier time of pronouncing words of a foreign language given their familiarity with using different parts of their speech anatomy. However, their ability to form sounds in languages they themselves do not speak suggests that humans can produce a finite amount of sounds. Nevertheless, this intersection of music and language leads me to conclude that if anyone can create an entirely new sound never heard before from instruments or people, it will be the work of a beatboxer.

Wikihow: How To Beatbox
http://www.wikihow.com/Beatbox
Standard Beatbox Notation (SBN) "Table 1"
http://allthingslinguistic.com/post/84361063129/the-science-of-b-b-b-beatboxing
Gretchen McCulloch's Article "The Science of B-B-B-Beatboxing"
http://www.slate.com/blogs/lexicon_valley/2014/04/30/beatboxing_using_mri_to_compare_a_beatboxer_s_sounds_to_language.html

3 comments:

  1. I found your post and the articles attached very interesting because I love to beatbox and I’ve always thought the ability to imitate percussion with vocal sounds is awesome. Before this linguistics class, I had never really thought of how the tongue and lips were so involved in beatboxing, but the videos featured in your articles made me much more aware of what actually occurs while beatboxing and how it all looks inside the mouth. One aspect of beatboxing that fascinates me is the ability to add voice while at the same time producing the various percussion sounds. Here is a perfect example of this:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0abzD7hBTRk

    I’ve tried to add my voice while beatboxing and it’s very difficult. I believe it has something to do with using your nasal passage in addition to your mouth to produce sounds, although I’m not entirely sure. I am very curious as to whether this ability has been closely analyzed to see how it is done so effectively.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is very interesting because not only do I find beatboxing to be fascinating but I am now interested in more about the intricacies of beat boxing. As you mentioned in your post, beatboxers can produce more sounds because they are accustomed to using different parts of their mouths to produce them. With the assumption that people do not start beatboxing when they are very young, such as less than five years old, I wonder if the claim that learning languages at an older age is more difficult because it is harder to make certain sounds is as true as I thought. If a person can learn how to beatbox, what is the difference between that and learning a new language and its sounds?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Until I read this post, I never made the connection that amongst my friends who can beatbox, nearly all of them stand-out with their phonetic capabilities. Amongst these individuals, one of my closer friends from high school was capable of affecting multiple accents and imitating people typically to poke fun in a surprisingly accurate manner. So in cumulative sense, he had all the desired attributes of a mimicry artist. However, although he could "beatbox" in a sense, from what I recall he never took it far enough to do so for a musical group like acapella and he never took a class for it. As a result, I am very curious to know what the actual relationship between beatboxing and phonetic potential is , because if beatboxing is a somewhat innate skill, then so might our phonetic capabilities.

    ReplyDelete